Fulford Battlefield Research Website


Planning & flooding along Germany Beck
 Recording the events of September 1066
tanged arrow from Fulford
yorks releif map

The Fulford Tapestry Website

What use politicians
Financial Times
Press Q&A produced for the Jorvi
Pictorial briefing
The Second Battle of Fulford
Planning & flooding along Germany Beck
News from 1066
Green paper
Lottery Grant
Impending decision
2005 Activities
Planning bias
Metal finds update
Some stories
Norwegian papers
David Aaronovitch BBC
Telegraph letter
Inquiry result
John Vidal
John Humphrys
A lucky find
Beginners Guide to Public Planni
Planning - Whose thinking big

York City Planning documents online


YouTube videos


The Final Report

Finding Fulford cover

Kindle edition of Finding Fulford is now available

The Fulford Tapestry


Visiting Fulford

Map York


The Editor

18 February 2008

Dear Sir

Thank you for the excellent photograph and article about the flooding along Germany Beck and the way the planning system doesn’t really work. I was standing beside Christine Dinsdale, whose alarm you report, when she showed the pictures and newspaper reports to the Planning Inspector during his site visit at the end of the Public Inquiry about Germany Beck.

The Inspector commented that it was ‘difficult’ when the official flooding line was contradicted by the evidence which various local people reported to him. The Inspector’s report however accepted the ‘official’ view that was given to him by the developers even though we had produced many images, covering a number of floods, that showed the floodwater reached a metre higher than the flood line used in the design.
This unreal approach to the facts continued.

On the same visit we encountered the hole of a water vole. The representative of the developers insisted that this must be ignored since ‘it had not been presented in evidence during the inquiry’. The Inspector went along with this madness and his report accepts the unsubstantiated view presented by the developer’s expert that Germany Beck is not a habitat for water voles, in spite of the evidence presented by those who knew the beck much better and, of course, the inescapable evidence of the hole of a water vole at his feet.

I do not believe that those operating the planning system are either stupid or dishonest so the fault must lie in the mad rules under which they operate which requires some inconvenient truths to be ignored.

Please continue with your enquiry as it is vital that some sense of reality creeps into this planning debate before the vital historic, environmental and recreational resource of Germany Beck is destroyed.


PS added in feb 2012

This was included in the report and the water voles have suffered terribly becuse they are in the wrong place in spite of police intervention. 

Related sites Facebook  Twitter (@ helpsavefulford)        Visiting Fulford        Map York

The author of the content is Charles Jones - fulfordthing@gmail.com   Last updated April 2015

This site does not use any cookies - so nothing is knowingly installed on your computer when browsing