Michael Courcier & Partner
Dear Mr Courcier
Germany Beck development
I recently inspected the planning application submitted on
behalf of Persimmon Homes and Hogg Builders for 700 dwellings in
the area known as Germany Beck. As
I plan to raise a detailed objection to the plan I wanted to make you aware in
the hope that a timely compromise would satisfy us both.
My concern is the preservation of the battle site and context
of the Battle of Fulford. Although
no mention of the battle is made in Ch14 on Cultural & Archaeological
of your Environmental Statement, in two supporting documents you do say that 'the
location of the Battle of Fulford…appears to be outside the development area'.
I am not sure on what evidence this statement is made. My understanding
is that the site of the battle is reckoned to cover the access road and Area B
on your plan. The plaque erected by the Parish Council would be feet away from
the access road. I therefore doubt that your assertion is correct.
I am in contact with English Heritage who have set some
stringent evidential requirements in order to gain a listing, with the
consequent protection from development. Without some investigation this will be
hard to provide. However, I hope that York City Council can be persuaded to
prevent any development until the necessary investigations have been carried
out. I am told that ancient battlefields do not make good sites for
archaeological investigation but a geophysical scan and licensed metal detecting
survey might give some pointers. In the absence of evidence I will encourage the
Council not to permit construction on the traditional site of the Battle.
Within your documentation, the archaeology of the access road
is not as well covered. This contrasts with the comprehensive investigations
within the area of the dwellings. I am sorry, for example, that the limited data
on the trenches Nos 20-29 was excluded from the detailed statement. These are in
the area of what I conjecture to be the final phase of the battle (although I
understand that the trenches did not go to a sufficient depth for my purposes).
Could I also suggest that the battle should be listed in Figure 15 to Appendix
I invite you to have a look at a web site I have prepared
where I have set out a possible narrative for the battle and have
appealed for evidence. I recently took a historian who reported regularly to the
outgoing Minister of Culture so I am optimistic that I can raise the awareness
of this issue. I now plan to provide a narrative for visitors on the site. If
you do not want me to include any information from your replies on the site
could you please make it clear.
I am attempting to make you aware of the problem at the
earliest possible moment. I have already tried to contact Persimmon and
their Archaeological Consultants but have been disappointed at their failure to
reply. Please would you encourage the contractors to give this matter their
urgent attention. I am not attempting to prevent the development but I am aware
that if my objection to the access route is sustained it will strangle the
project. My interest is to identify and conserve the battlesite. I believe that
it is also in the interests of your clients.
Related sites Facebook Twitter (@ helpsavefulford) Visiting Fulford Map York
The author of the content is Charles Jones - firstname.lastname@example.org Last updated April 2015
This site does not use any cookies - so nothing is knowingly installed on your computer when browsing